logo
  • Home
  • The Biblical Gospel Which is the Only Way of Salvation
  • The Great Commission
  • Return to the Articles of Confederation
  • Protestant Nationalism Proffered
  • Historic Puritan Presbyterianism
  • Historicism Research Foundation
  • Puritans Home School Curriculum
  • Americans for an Anglo-American Nation
  • In Defense of Christian Ethnic Homeland Nations
  • Young Earth Creationism
  • The Reformation Party
  • Rising Atmospheric Carbon Dioxide Level Is Beneficial
  • “Save The Campbell”- Thwart the Net Zero Agenda
  • Local Bible-Based Approach to Politics
    • County and Township Supported Neighborhood Watch Program
    • County and Township Supported and Authorized Citizens Militia
    • Example Letter to Township Leaders Seeking Election Integrity and Neighborhood Watch Support
  • Online Westminster Covenant Academy
  • Covid-19 Pandemic
    • Information on the Covid Vaccine
    • Through Which Prism Should We Consider It?
    • Investigations into its Material Origins
    • Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland Sermons on the Topic
      • Isaiah 2:22 by Mr. MacColl
  • Links
    • General Political Articles
    • General Religious Articles
    • Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland
    • Hold Fast
    • History of Mankind from the Perspective of One Man’s Genealogical Journey
    • Politically Conservative Websites
    • Conservative American Patriot Sanctuary Counties

The book of Philemon in the Bible is important to consider on the topic of slavery. The standard interpretation of Philemon in older commentaries (John Calvin, Matthew Henry, and many others) goes something like this:

– Slaveholding is not sinful per se. If slaveholding were sinful per se, then surely the Apostle Paul would have rebuked Philemon for being a slaveholder and would not have sent Onesimus back to Philemon. What would be the point of sending Onesimus back to Philemon, if slaveholding is immoral? For example, if Philemon had been a brothel owner (which is per se sinful) and there were a runaway whore, would the Apostle Paul have addressed the matter in the way he addressed this case, by sending the woman back to the pimp?

– The arguments of verses 13-14 assume that Onesimus was rightfully the chattel slave of Philemon, such that it was Philemon’s choice to decide how Onesimus would be employed. As John Calvin points out, “Paul himself, through modesty, was unwilling to deprive Philemon of his right”.

– In verse 16, when it reads “not now as a servant”, the Apostle Paul did not mean Onesimus was no longer a servant (or chattel slave) of Philemon, but (as Matthew Henry comments) he meant “not merely or so much” a servant. In other words, there is an implied “merely”, even if not express, as can be deduced from the overall context.

In contrast, many modern commentaries interpret verse 16 as stating that Onesimus was being returned to Philemon, but not as a servant. They view chattel slavery as per se wrong, and they assert the Apostle Paul viewed it as wrong, and hence said Onesimus was being returned but not as servant. For instance, Nelson’s Bible Dictionary, as published in 1986, says that the Apostle Paul expected “that Philemon would receive Onesimus back as a brother in the Lord, not as a slave (v. 16)”, as if the two were inherently contradictory. Nelson’s goes on to say that “although Paul never, so far as we know, called for an end to slavery, the Epistle to Philemon laid the ax at the root of that cruel and deformed institution…”

But this modern interpretation begs the obvious question: why is Onesimus even being returned to Philemon if Onesimus has no ownership rights over him? Furthermore, if slavery is inherently sinful, then how do we account for the Old Testament treatment on slavery, combined with no clear statement in the New Testament that chattel slavery is wrong? Where in the Bible can we clearly deduce that slaveholding is a sin? Or is this instead a modern Western view being imposed upon the Biblical text? And if it is an imposition, then it contradicts the Biblical doctrine of sola scriptura.

I believe the Bible, exhibited in the book of Philemon, teaches that chattel slavery is an appropriate punishment for sinful rebellion, and that in a Fallen sinful world slavery can be an appropriate civil response to criminal behavior, some forms of debt which cannot be repaid, conquered enemies in a lawful war, etc. Even the Michigan constitution, which in general prohibits slavery, recognizes its appropriateness as punishment for some forms of criminal behavior. Slavery in various circumstances can be the merciful response. And God has mercifully used it to bring some to Christ who likely would not otherwise have done so. Contrary to the modern view, the Bible teaches that all of Adam’s sinful race deserve to be chattel slaves eternally, which is why Jesus Christ vicariously became a suffering servant to redeem His people.

The book of Philemon also teaches the great value of the Biblical gospel, and hence the great debt owed by recipients of that gospel to the human instruments bringing that gospel. We read in Philemon verse 19: “I Paul have written it with mine own hand, I will repay it: albeit I do not say to thee how thou owest unto me even thine own self besides.” Philemon owed much to the Apostle Paul because he was the human instrument bringing the gospel to Philemon. Such was also the role played by Protestant white slaveholders in relation to their black slaves brought from paganism in Africa. As expressed by the Puritan Rev. Cotton Mather in his booklet “The Negro Christianized”: “Christianity does Marvellously befriend and enrich and advance Mankind. The greatest Kindness that can be done to any Man is to make a Christian of him. Your Negroes are immediately Raised unto an astonishing Felicity, when you have Christianized them. They are become amiable spectacles, & such as the Angels of God would gladly repair unto the Windows of Heaven to look upon.” This past period in redemptive history thus played a positive role in bringing people from paganism to Christianity. It contradicts the Bible to sue for reparations what instead should be looked upon with gratitude. This does not mean at this point we should return to race-based slavery of blacks; we should not. Rather, at this point in redemptive history we should be seeking that all nations, including ones majority black and ruled by blacks, should “kiss the Son”. This should be our goal now that Christianity has been brought to blacks and many have at least nominally embraced, and some savingly.

« The Historical Roots of the Current Anglo-American Struggle Against Imperial Tyranny
Resources on South African Prime Minister Hendrick Verwoerd »

Leave a comment Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pages

  • “Save The Campbell”- Thwart the Net Zero Agenda
  • 2023-06-19 Letter to Commissioner Zylstra Concerning the Articles of Confederation
  • A Biblical Approach to Human Phylogenetics
  • A History of Mankind from the Perspective of My Genealogical Journey
  • Additional Articles
  • Additional Articles
  • All Eyes Upon Texas
  • Americans for an Anglo-American Nation
  • Americans for the Deportation of All Illegal Immigrants
  • An Anglo-American Patriot Agenda
  • Anglo-America/index.htm
  • Area Volunteers in Ottawa County-MI
  • Article Archives
  • Attorney Lin Wood Explains Chinese Money Behind Much of the Fraud
  • Bannon’s War Room
  • Biblical Predictions Not Preterist But Historicist
  • Biblical Protestant Repentance Is Key to Christian Liberty
  • Big League Politics
  • Book Entitled “Return to the Articles of Confederation”
  • Breitbart
  • Calvin on Islam
  • Chinese Involvement With Biden
  • Communist China takeover of US Companies
  • Conservative American Patriot Sanctuary Counties
  • County and Township Supported and Authorized Citizens Militia
  • County and Township Supported Neighborhood Watch Program
  • County Organizers by County-State
  • Countywide Neighborhood Watch and Emergency Assistance Network
  • Covid-19 Pandemic
    • Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland Sermons on the Topic
      • Isaiah 2:22 by Mr. MacColl
    • Investigations into its Material Origins
    • Through Which Prism Should We Consider It?
  • Daniel’s Eschatology
  • Dardanus
  • Data Security Chief Admits Ability to Rig
  • Data Security Chief is Antifa Partisan
  • Democrat Party Election Fraud Machine
    • Example Communication to State Legislator Requesting Investigations
    • Example Communication to State Legislator Requesting That No Electors Be Sent If Fraud Cannot be Corrected in Time
    • Lou Dobbs of Fox News Interviews Sidney Powell of Pres. Trump’s Legal Team
  • Draft Christian Constitutional Amendment for Michigan
  • Eaters of Children
  • Election Integrity Alliance
  • Email Communication to Georgetown Township Board
  • Email to Church
  • Email to Georgetown Township Board
  • Examination of Dominion Voting Systems
  • Example Email to Ottawa County Board Commissioner Regarding the Articles of Confederation and the Federal Constitution Dated 04/25/23
  • Example Letter to Township Leaders Seeking Election Integrity and Neighborhood Watch Support
  • Exposing the Fraud by Analyzing the Data
  • Follow Up Email to Church
  • Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland
  • General Political Articles
  • General Religious Articles
  • Georgetown Township Neighborhood Watch and Emergency Assistance Network
  • Historic Puritan Presbyterianism
  • Historicism Research Foundation
  • History of Mankind from the Perspective of One Man’s Genealogical Journey
  • Hold Fast
  • How Communist China Curries Political Favors
  • HRF Reading Materials
  • HRF’s Founding Advisor
  • Information on the Covid Vaccine
  • Islam in the Bible
  • John’s Historicistic Epistles
  • John’s Revelation Unveiled
  • Lessons from the Zionist Movement for Anglo-American Patriots
  • Letter Requesting Support for an Afrikaner Homeland Nation by J. Parnell McCarter
  • Letter to Georgetown Township Board on 01/01/2021
  • Letter to Jared Taylor dated 04-02-2023
  • letter to NRC minister dated 04-22-2023 regarding NRC project
  • Letter to Ottawa County Board and Clerk Regarding Election Integrity Dated 04/12/2021
  • Letter to Ottawa County Board Regarding Diversity and Inclusion Office Dated 03/03/2021
  • Letter to Ottawa County Board Regarding Election Integrity Dated 02/22/2021
  • Letter to Ottawa County Board Regarding the Second Amendment Dated 03/06/2021
  • Letter to the Elders of the NRC of Grand Rapids Dated March 13, 2023
  • Links
    • “Ek is ‘n Suidlander”
  • Local Bible-Based Approach to Politics
  • Luther on Islam and the Papacy
  • Massive Fraud Uncovered By Analysis
  • May 2023 Political Events in Ottawa County: Resolution as a Constitutional County
  • Michael Cresap
  • Michelle Malkin Interview of Joe Oltmann
  • Michigan Alliance of Christian Anglo-American Electors
  • MIT Scientist Exposes Election Fraud in Michigan by Analysis
  • My Genealogy Back to Archibald Campbell III (earl of Argyle)
  • My Genealogy Back to Daniel McNamara of County Clare, Ireland
  • My Genealogy Back to James Alexander McCarter and Earlier
  • My Genealogy Back to James Stuart, 2nd Earl of Moray, and Robert the Bruce
  • My Genealogy Back to King Arthur of the Britons and Further Back to Dardanus
  • My Genealogy Back to Sir Hugh Montgomery
  • My Genealogy Back to the Johnsons and Slaydens of Colonial Virginia
  • My Genealogy Back to Thomas Cresap of Maryland
  • My Genealogy Back to Thomas Edgerly of Massachusetts Bay Colony
  • Natural News
  • Northlanders (North American Friends of the Suidlanders)
  • NTD News
  • One Sordid Aspect of the Widespread US Corruption
  • Original Articles
  • Pandemic War Room
  • Parallel Histories
  • Politically Conservative Websites
    • 100% Fed Up
    • Bannon’s War Room
    • Newsmax
    • OAN News
    • Parler
  • Prophetic Chart
  • Protestant Nationalism Proffered
  • Puritans Home School Curriculum
  • Raise America’s First National Flag
  • Rational and Avenue For A Biblical Community In The Greater Grand Rapids Area
  • Reading List Towards Formation of Biblical Communities in North America
  • Red State Secession
  • Referendum and Rationale for Partition of Michigan
  • ReformedOnline
  • Request to the Governing Boards in Ottawa County, Michigan
  • Resource Books on the Articles of Confederation
  • Return to the Articles of Confederation
  • Rev. A Brakel’s Commentary on Revelation
  • Rev. A Brakel’s Commentary on Revelation
  • Rising Atmospheric Carbon Dioxide Level Is Beneficial
  • Rulers of Evil
  • SGT Report
  • Stop The Steal
  • The Anti-Preterist Historicism of John Calvin and the Westminster Standards
  • The Biblical Gospel Which is the Only Way of Salvation
  • The Chinese Connection
  • The Epoch Times
  • The Gateway Pundit
  • The Great Commission
  • The Man of Sin in Second Thessalonians
  • The Olivet Discourse and the Destruction of Jerusalem in Prophecy
  • The Papacy is the Antichrist
  • The Past Provides A Blueprint Towards An Anglo-American Nation
  • The Religious Contest Between the Original Constitution and the Usurping Constitution of the USA
  • The Right Scoop
  • The Rise and Fall of the Papacy by Rev. Robert Fleming
  • The Sixth Point of Calvinism: Eschato-Ethics
  • Thomas Cresap
  • USA.Life
  • What Should We Think of the Old South African Apartheid System?
  • Where Do We Likely Go From Here?
  • Worldnetdaily
  • Worldview Weekend
  • Young Earth Creationism
  • Zero Hedge
  • Zionist Example
  • Home
  • Free Online Manual for Implementing the Curriculum
  • Catalog of Books by Catalog #
  • Catalog of Textbooks by Subject
  • Advice on Use
  • Online Westminster Covenant Academy
  • Historicism Research Foundation
  • Miscellaneous
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

Archives

  • March 2023
  • November 2020
  • March 2020
  • October 2019
  • August 2019

Categories

  • Uncategorized (7)

WordPress

  • Log in
  • WordPress

Subscribe

  • Entries (RSS)
  • Comments (RSS)